Year: 2022
Author: Plebuch, Jonas, Pielhoff, Simon
Der Staat, Vol. 61 (2022), Iss. 2 : pp. 167–203
Abstract
The German Verwaltungsstaat as a Democratic Ideal – the U.S. American Administrative State as a Threat to Democracy?
German and American Administrative Law Between Convergence and Divergence
U.S. legal scholarship has been debating the legitimacy of the federal administrative and regulatory state for decades. Some legal arguments, such as the unitary executive theory or the nondelegation doctrine, are strikingly similar to German doctrines on the relationship between the executive and the other powers. At the same time, we can observe tendencies in Germany that run contrary to developments in the U.S.: de-hierarchization, de-judicialization, de-parliamentarization. In this paper, we analyze whether these developments in fact converge – Is American administrative law becoming more German and German administrative law more American? We introduce the U.S. debate and its historical and constitutional background in comparison to the German discussion. Our main observation is that the legal figures converge in substance, but their historical and political contexts diverge to such an extent that we cannot meaningfully diagnose convergences. Our observations, so we argue, allow us to draw two theoretical hypotheses. The first is on the relationship between legal concepts and their historical background; the second is on the methodological significance of context in comparative constitutional and administrative law.
You do not have full access to this article.
Already a Subscriber? Sign in as an individual or via your institution
Journal Article Details
Publisher Name: Global Science Press
Language: German
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3790/staa.61.2.167
Der Staat, Vol. 61 (2022), Iss. 2 : pp. 167–203
Published online: 2022-04
AMS Subject Headings: Duncker & Humblot
Copyright: COPYRIGHT: © Global Science Press
Pages: 37
Author Details
| Section Title | Page | Action | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jonas Plebuch/Simon Pielhoff: Verwaltungsstaat als Demokratieideal – Administrative State als Demokratiegefahr? Deutsches und amerikanisches Verwaltungsrecht zwischen Konvergenz und Divergenz | 167 | ||
| I. Einführung | 167 | ||
| II. Verwaltungsrecht vergeht, Verfassungsrecht besteht – die US-amerikanische Debatte im Spiegel der deutschen Entwicklung | 169 | ||
| 1. Welche Verwaltung als Vergleichsgegenstand? | 169 | ||
| 2. Deutschland | 172 | ||
| 3. USA | 167 | ||
| III. Wird das amerikanische Verwaltungsrecht deutscher und das deutsche Verwaltungsrecht amerikanischer? | 169 | ||
| 1. Konvergenzen in der Sache | 169 | ||
| 2. Divergenzen in den Kontexten | 169 | ||
| 3. Äpfel mit Äpfeln vergleichen – Lehren aus dem Vergleich | 169 |